Back
Close
  • Compare agents
  • Online valuation
  • Explore my area
  • Home toolkit
  • News & guides
Sign In To Agent Shortlist
Agent Shortlist
Sign In To HouseWorth
HouseWorth
  • Estate agents by area
  • Sold house prices by area
Search by Location or Name
  • Selling guides
  • Estate agent guides
  • Mortgage advice
  • Conveyancing guides
  • Property news
  • See All News & Guides
Sign in
Sign In To Agent Shortlist

Agent shortlist

Sign In To HouseWorth

HouseWorth

© GetAgent Limited 2026
  1. Estate Agents in Cayton

Compare the Best 10 Estate Agents in Cayton

See Fees, Sale Times and Reviews for Cayton Estate Agents

Looking for the best estate agents in Cayton? In the last 6 months, 45 properties have been listed for sale, and the average asking price in Cayton is £267,554. Homes typically take 21 weeks to go under offer. Fees from participating agents active locally average 1.44% including VAT, with a typical range of 0.96%–1.8%. These fees are evaluated at the area’s average listing value of £267,272 and weighted by sales-listing activity over the past six months. They are estimates, not individual quotes.

Cayton Property Market Summary
  • Average asking price£267,554
  • Average sale time21 weeks
  • Asking price change-1.7%
  • Average estate agent fee incl. VAT1.44%

Based on 6 participating agents at an average area listing value of £267,272. Calculated 2026-10-26.

See the fee calculator and methodology
See the full breakdown of .

Find out how much your property is worth

Get an instant online valuation in just a few seconds!
Get started

There aren't any agents with branches in Cayton, but these are the agents that have listed properties in this area.

List of Estate Agents in Cayton

Showing 1 - 10 of 10
  1. Carter Jonas - York Logo

    Carter Jonas - York

    82 Micklegate,York, YO1 6LF
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (159 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    11th Oct 2026 (16 days ago)
    Recently moved into my first flat with my partner, Freya was very lovely she was an amazing help throughout the process and made everything go smoothly. 5 stars for her specifically!... Read more
  2. Blenkin & Co - York Logo

    Blenkin & Co - York

    36 Bootham, York, YO30 7BL
    Average 4.7/5 Stars

    (104 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    23rd Sep 2026 (5 weeks ago)
    Excellent support throughout our purchase from Angela Brader. Angela really drove the process despite the numerous challenges presented and was stoic and professional throughout. Quality, and professionalism championed by the whole team.... Read more
  3. CPH Property Services Logo

    CPH Property Services

    19 St. Thomas Street, YO11 1DY
    Average 4.3/5 Stars

    (11 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    26th Sep 2026 (4 weeks ago)
    Highly recommend. Kept updated throughout and everything ran smoothly. Thank you CPH.... Read more
  4. Reeds Rains - Scarborough Logo

    Reeds Rains - Scarborough

    16 Aberdeen Walk, YO11 1XP
    Average 4.8/5 Stars

    (371 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    26th Sep 2026 (4 weeks ago)
    We are selling my late mother's house and Reeds Raines have been amazing in getting the house on the market swiftly and efficiently. Huge credit due to Lauren for organising everything so smoothly! ?????? Would highly recommend Reeds Raines.... Read more
  5. Nicholsons - Filey Logo

    Nicholsons - Filey

    25 Belle Vue Street, Filey, YO14 9HU
    Average 3.4/5 Stars

    (38 reviews)

    Average 1/5 Stars
    3rd May 2026 (25 weeks ago)
    Connected to them via Rightmove for property in Scarborough. Can't help put you through to Scarborough Estate agents section. The estate agent department in Scarborough have recently informed me they are under no obligation to tell me anything negative about a property, they do not have to disclose anything such as management fund arrears.....even though the same company manage the building...... Read more
  6. Colin Ellis Estate Agents - Scarborough Logo

    Colin Ellis Estate Agents - Scarborough

    49 Aberdeen Walk, Scarborough, North Yorkshire, YO11 1BD
    Average 5.0/5 Stars

    (5 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    4th Sep 2025 (1 year ago)
    From Valuation onwards through marketing and liaison with the Sales team, the performance of the agent was exceptional. The customer service was efficient warm and friendly with attention to detail and the personal touch made it a delight using them, I got a great service and they travelled to Hunmanby from Scarborough to do the valuations, they were always there early so as not to keep the viewers waiting, whereas in my experience with some other local agents this is not a consideration. During the stressful conveyancing process with Solicitors between Exchange and Completion Tracey and her colleagues gave a massive amount of support and as I have moved numerous times over the years, I can tell you Colin Ellis are the best in North Yorkshire, also their fees too are highly competitive which helps tremendously especially when moving home. You won't be disappointed go with the best believe me my review can be verified and trusted. Many thanks Colin Ellis from Jane Hall, recently sold bungalow in Hunmanby near Filey Last week... Read more
  7. Nicholsons Yorkshire Coast Estate Agents - Scarborough Logo

    Nicholsons Yorkshire Coast Estate Agents - Scarborough

    4 Valley Bridge ParadeScarborough, YO11 2PF
    Average 2.3/5 Stars

    (23 reviews)

    Average 1/5 Stars
    22nd May 2021 (5 years ago)
    Shocking, avoid at all costs. Dishonest, rude and unprofessional.... Read more
  8. Hunters - Scarborough Logo

    Hunters - Scarborough

    33 Huntriss Row, Scarborough, North Yorkshire, YO11 2ED
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (66 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    9th Oct 2026 (18 days ago)
    I wanted to take a moment to write this review, particularly to thank the lovely lady from Hunters who showed me around several apartments on the Esplanade in Scarborough yesterday afternoon.<br><br>She was an absolute pleasure to meet , friendly, knowledgeable, and incredibly generous with her time. Her enthusiasm for the properties was infectious, and she made the whole experience relaxed and enjoyable.<br><br>I understand she has only recently joined Hunters, but if my experience is anything to go by, she will be a real asset to the team.<br><br>Thank you for making my visit such a pleasant experience.... Read more
  9. Ellis Hay Logo

    Ellis Hay

    14 Aberdeen Walk, Scarborough, YO11 1XP
    Average 5.0/5 Stars

    (2 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    27th Sep 2026 (30 days ago)
    Ellis Hay and in particular Gary did me proud. There were some challenges involved in selling my house but Gary stuck by us; always totally supportive. Nothing was too much trouble. We really appreciate the great service and kindness... Read more
  10. Liam Darrell Estate Agents - Scarborough Logo

    Liam Darrell Estate Agents - Scarborough

    85 Columbus Ravine, Scarborough, YO12 7QU
    Average 4.9/5 Stars

    (366 reviews)

    Average 5/5 Stars
    25th Oct 2026 (2 days ago)
    Great service. Recently contacted to view a house. Ultimately it wasn't for us, but these were a breath of fresh air.... Read more

Agents in this area will typically be able to sell your house in Cayton Bay, Eastfield, Flixton, Flixton Ings, Folkton, Gristhorpe, Hunmanby and Irton. If you're looking for an estate agent in Lebberston, Muston, Primrose Valley Holiday Village and Staxton and other local areas, the majority of these agents will also be able to help you sell your house too.

Choosing the right estate agent in Cayton matters more than most sellers realise. With 10 agents currently active across the area, performance varies considerably - some agents keep price changes to a minimum while others regularly make larger reductions. GetAgent pulls together verified sales data for every agent listed here so you can compare them on what actually counts: how quickly they sell, how much they typically reduce asking prices by, and what previous sellers say about working with them.

How to Compare Estate Agents in Cayton

1

Find Local Agents

Enter your Cayton postcode to see local agents ranked by performance.

2

Compare Their Performance

Compare fees, average sale time and percentage of asking price achieved in Cayton.

3

Book Free Valuations

Book free, no-obligation valuations with the agents that fit, and choose the right one for your sale.

FAQs

Explore agents near Cayton

Are you thinking of selling?

Our friendly team of experts are here to guide you through the process of selling your property. Give us a ring for some free advice on how to choose the right agent for you.
  • 020 3608 6556
  • Our lines are closed
Excellent
10,010 reviews onTrustpilot

Compare all Estate Agents in Cayton

Compare agent performance and fees, and find the best one to sell your home.
  • Data-driven recommendations
  • No obligation
  • Fast & easy

Compare all Estate Agents in Cayton

Compare agent performance and fees, and find the best one to sell your home.
  • Data-driven recommendations
  • No obligation
  • Fast & easy

Get a property valuation

Get your FREE, personalised valuation report now!

  • Historical price changes and trends
  • Area demand analysis
  • List of best performing local agents
Property Value Report

Related posts

Estate agent leads a family around a potential new home.
Estate agent leads a family around a potential new home.

Estate Agents

What do estate agents do?

For each home sale there are several steps estate agents have to follow, and a minefield of legal requirements they have to comply with.…

Read more

The Estate Agent comparison site
GetAgent LinkedIn iconGetAgent Facebook iconGetAgent X icon

Get in touch

020 3608 6556

Our lines are closed


We are a company registered in England & Wales, company number 09428979.

Copyright © 2026 GetAgent Limited